Travel Safety in Perspective: USA vs. Mexico

Zacatecas - older than Boston, and safer

There’s been a lot of news coverage about violence in Mexico, very little of it bothering to note that Mexico is a huge country with thirty-some states and that a) almost all of that violence is narco-related and b) you can count the number of tourists affected on one hand.

Meanwhile, according to the FBI, “An estimated 15,241 persons were murdered nationwide in 2009” in the United States of America.

Officially, 111 U.S. citizens were killed in Mexico last year, a third in just two cities. Almost all of them were involved in illicit vocations, usually the trafficking of guns, drugs, or people across the border. This is 111 out of close to 8 million visitors, with nearly 1 million of those being part- or full-time residents choosing Mexico over the U.S. or Canada.

You know who else had 111 murders in one year recently? Boston. And Las Vegas. And Orlando. Are any tourists scared of going to those places?

Meanwhile, almost 1,000 U.S. citizens died in Puerto Rico. Nobody running the news desks cares about Puerto Rico or has an incentive to make people scared of Puerto Ricans (by nature, they can’t be “illegal immigrants”), so this isn’t widely reported.

Then there’s the U.S. proper, which can’t get a State Department travel alert because it’s, well, not a foreign country. How’s your city doing in comparison to Mexico when it comes to the annual numbers?

Atlanta  – city, 80 murders. Atlanta MSA (metropolitan statistical area), 325 murders
Baltimore – 238 city, 298 MSA
Boston – 50 city, 111 MSA
Dallas/Ft. Worth – 210 city, 310 MSA
Detroit – 365 city, 447 MSA
Houston – 287 city, 462 MSA
Indianapolis – 100 city, 111 MSA
Jacksonville, FL – 99 city, 120 MSA
Kansas City – 100 city, 163 MSA
Las Vegas – 111 city, 133 MSA
Los Angeles – 312 city, 768 MSA
Miami  – 59 city, 377 Miami to Boca Raton corridor
New Orleans – 174 city, 252 MSA
New York City – 471 city, 778 MSA
Orlando – 28 city, 111 MSA
Philadelphia – 302 city, 436 MSA
Phoenix – 122 city, 302 MSA
San Francisco – 45 city, 292 MSA
St. Louis – 143 city, 210 MSA
Washington, DC – 143 city, 325 MSA

To put things in perspective, the murder rate in the Yucatan state of Mexico is 2 per 100,000. That’s about the same as Fond du Lac, Wisconsin or Evansville, Indiana. Mexico City’s is 8 per 100,000. Despite being one of the most populated cities on the planet, that’s on par with Albuquerque, NM. I don’t know about you, but I’ve never felt scared in Albuquerque…

 

 

Don’t miss out – snag the Cheapest Destinations RSS feed!

75 Comments

  1. Dave 05/18/2011
    • tim 05/18/2011
      • Randy 05/24/2011
  2. PKL 05/19/2011
    • tim 05/19/2011
  3. Br1an 05/19/2011
    • tim 05/19/2011
      • Mike 07/13/2011
        • tim 07/14/2011
    • Eleanor 04/10/2016
      • Tim Leffel 04/12/2016
  4. Bodie 05/19/2011
  5. PKL 05/20/2011
  6. Julie 05/20/2011
  7. Angela 05/20/2011
    • ken hingey 05/27/2011
  8. Sheila 05/21/2011
    • Veronica 05/25/2011
  9. Bonnie 05/22/2011
  10. Lettie 05/23/2011
  11. Hans 05/24/2011
  12. Jen 05/24/2011
  13. Josh 05/24/2011
    • Deborah 07/10/2011
  14. John de Waal 05/24/2011
  15. dixie 05/24/2011
  16. sean 05/24/2011
    • tim 05/24/2011
  17. Cheryl 05/25/2011
    • tim 05/25/2011
  18. Andrea 05/25/2011
  19. dana 05/25/2011
    • anne 12/19/2011
      • tim 12/20/2011
  20. Michy 05/25/2011
  21. joanne 05/26/2011
  22. ken hingey 05/27/2011
  23. Erin 05/28/2011
  24. Geoff 05/31/2011
  25. Victoria, Bucerias, Mexico 06/01/2011
  26. Russ 06/01/2011
  27. Carlos 06/01/2011
  28. Kelly 06/02/2011
    • tim 06/02/2011
  29. marci 06/05/2011
    • tim 06/06/2011
  30. Linda 06/06/2011
  31. eric 06/21/2011
  32. Teddi 07/10/2011
  33. Mike 07/12/2011
    • tim 07/12/2011
  34. Mario 07/12/2011
    • Mike 07/13/2011
  35. Jeremy 07/24/2011
  36. Maksym 08/21/2011
  37. tim 08/24/2011
  38. Miguel 12/27/2011
  39. Lord Wayne 01/29/2012
  40. Scott 02/06/2012
    • tim 02/07/2012

Leave a Reply